evolution's tomfoolery--10/28/26
Today's selection--from On The Future of Species by Adrian Woolfson. The human body contains vestiges of an irrelevant evolutionary past carried forward into the present:
“Unlike the George Washington Bridge, which was anchored on solid rock, the Tappan Zee [Bridge was poorly located at a wide part of the river and] required an elaborate underwater flotation system. The cost of building this, along with the bridge's excessive dimensions, strained an already inadequate budget. A materials shortage precipitated by the onset of the Korean War served only to compound the problem, leading to shoddy construction. Completed in 1955, the bridge rapidly fell into disrepair and was demolished in 2017. This provided the perfect opportunity to correct an irrelevant, historically defined feature by relocating the bridge to a narrower part of the crossing. But by then, an extensive infrastructure had grown around its original location, making relocation impractical. The replacement bridge was, as a result, constructed alongside the position of the original, thereby perpetuating a historically contingent suboptimal design.
“Biological systems, including the human body, contain their own Tappan Zees – vestiges of an irrelevant past carried forward into the present. These evolutionary relics continue to constrain our biology. The causes of many such awkward anomalies originated long before the evolution of our species, yet they reverberate across biological time, undermining our biology. One such 'Tappan Zee' is the human spine.
“While well suited to the lifestyle of our quadrupedal, tree-dwelling ape ancestors, the morphology of the human spine is poorly adapted for walking on two legs. Evolution has, nevertheless, succeeded in awkwardly reconfiguring the original design to accommodate its new bipedal function. But this is akin to trying to fit a square peg into a round hole. To support an upright posture, the angle between the femur and the hip gradually widened, the pelvic structures readjusted, and the spine acquired its characteristic inward curve. This remarkable and unlikely transformation was like turning a table into a chair. That it succeeded at all is a testament to the extraordinary malleability of biology systems and the generative power of Darwinian evolution.
“The resultant remodelled anatomy, however, is far from what one would design by choice, especially from a biomechanical standpoint. The human spine is, in fact, a design disaster. Were it possible to redesign it from scratch, it would not be modelled on the design of a creature that walked on four legs. Bruce Latimer, an anatomist at Case Western Reserve University, in Cleveland, Ohio, likened the unwieldy rotation of a spine by the ninety degrees necessary to make it vertical for bipedal walking to 'stacking 26 cups and saucers on top of each other', and then 'balancing a head on top'. The vertebrae are the cups; the discs between them, the saucers. In this new configuration, the weight of the head places constant, excessive pressure on these fragile structures.
![]() |
| The human spinal column and its regions |
“But this 'jerry-rigged' redesign of the spine had to operate within very tight parameters. Chief among these was the need to accommodate the pelvic birth canal. Humans give birth to babies with much larger bodies and brains than primate babies, necessitating a large pelvis. Unfortunately, these two features – bipedal locomotion and childbirth – have conflicting design needs. While delivering a baby requires a wide pelvis, walking upright favours a narrow one. The evolutionary compromise was an inward-curving spine with its characteristic 'S' shape, accommodating both functions, albeit imperfectly. This compromise has left us prone to back pain, vertebral fractures and obstetric complications.
“Our feet, too, are poorly designed, representing another anatomical compromise. Anthropologist Jeremy DeSilva at Boston University has used the human foot as an example of how evolution 'works with duct tape and paper clips' to patch solutions together quickly. Had you asked an engineer to design a human foot, they would have been unlikely to make it with so many moving parts. Its exuberant deployment of bones is especially notable when one realises that the twenty-six bones in the foot account for a quarter of all the bones in the human body.
“While this configuration is well suited for tree-dwelling apes that need to grasp branches, it is both unnecessary and cumbersome for a bipedal species. Though evolution has attempted to bolster its rigidity, the human foot remains susceptible to inward and outward twisting, and its arches prone to collapse. These vulnerabilities lead to a host of ailments and afflictions including tendonitis, plantar fasciitis and broken ankles. Had we been consulted, we might have fashioned our feet more like those of ostriches, whose ankle and lower-leg bones are fused into a single, powerful structure optimised for walking and running.
“One of the most striking biological examples of an anatomical 'Tappan Zee' is the eccentric distribution of the left recurrent laryngeal nerve. The anatomy of this nerve, which facilitates sound production in the larynx, has a highly irrational feature. While the right recurrent laryngeal nerve branches off from the vagus nerve as it exits the brain at the base of the skull and proceeds directly to the larynx, the left eschews this direct course, embarking instead on a bizarre detour. It passes down in front of the aorta, loops underneath and behind it, performing a U-turn before ascending back up to the larynx, ending up essentially where it started. It is hard to imagine any advantage to this circuitous path, and a rational engineer would never have designed it that way.
“The left recurrent laryngeal nerve's eccentric route is, however, more than just a curiosity. It comes with jeopardy. Compression, ischaemia or injury to the left recurrent laryngeal nerve is more common than on the right, and may result in left-sided vocal cord paralysis. While relatively rare in humans, in long-necked species like horses, this anatomical quirk can cause significant issues. Horses, for example, are prone to develop a condition called equine recurrent laryngeal neuropathy. This is predominantly left-sided, and may cause respiratory problems. It is especially pronounced in racehorses, their size and elongated necks making them particularly susceptible. In the long-necked African giraffe, the nerve's convoluted route can extend to a staggering fifteen feet. Had the nerve been routed directly to the larynx, a length of one foot would have sufficed. The left recurrent laryngeal nerve of the gargantuan, long-necked, sauropod dinosaur Supersaurus – living between 230 and 66 million years ago, and with a neck six times the length of a giraffe's – would have been subject to a detour of up to ninety-two feet. It provides a striking example of evolution's tomfoolery.”





COMMENTS (0)
Notice: Trying to access array offset on value of type bool in /home/customer/www/delanceyplace.com/public_html/cmsAdmin/plugins/websiteComments/websiteComments.php on line 279